The Old Red Lion Theatre - Islington - Pub Reviews

Name: The Old Red Lion Theatre Pub
Location: 418 St John Street, London, EC1V 4NJ
Phone: 020 7837 7816

Opening Hours:

• Monday to Thursday: 11:00–23:00

• Friday to Saturday: 11:00–00:00

• Sunday: 12:00–22:30

Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.1)

Facilities & Entertainment:

• Parking: No

• Darts & Pool Table: No

• Live Sports: No

Food on Offer:
The pub features a concise menu of classic British pub dishes, including hearty burgers and fish & chips. There are usually vegetarian and vegan offerings as well, such as a tasty plant-based burger or a fresh salad. Occasional specials pop up, especially on weekends, and Sunday roasts are a highlight that many regulars seem to rave about.

Beers on Tap:
Expect a solid choice of real ales and rotating guest brews, reflecting the pub’s dedication to quality craft beer. You’ll find popular British standards alongside local London ales, plus at least one seasonal option that changes periodically.

Price Range:
Generally in the ££ range. A hearty meal and a pint won’t break the bank, and most patrons find the cost fair for central London.

Customer Service:
The staff consistently receive praise for their welcoming attitude and prompt service. Some reviews mention a genuine warmth that makes you feel at home straight away. In my experience, I felt looked after from the moment I walked in, with the bartenders quick to recommend a local ale and chat about the day’s theatre schedule.

Events & Special Nights:
The upstairs theatre hosts rotating plays, comedy nights, and experimental performances, adding a cultural edge to the typical pub-going experience. On select evenings, there may also be special events in the bar area—though the theatre remains the star attraction, especially for fans of fringe and new writing.

In-Depth Review

I’ve often walked past The Old Red Lion Theatre Pub, intrigued by its charming exterior and the promise of live theatre upstairs. Nestled on St John Street in Angel, this historic venue dates back to the late 19th century and still exudes an old-world charm that many modern pubs lack. Part of its allure is the way it has retained a sense of character over the years—wood-panelled walls, vintage-style seating, and a cosy fireplace corner that’s particularly inviting on chilly London evenings.

What truly sets it apart from other pubs in Islington is its thriving theatre space above the main bar. This second-floor venue is small and intimate, perfect for catching the latest in fringe theatre or a thought-provoking new play. I’ve found that the crowd here is a diverse mix: you’ll see theatre buffs coming straight from rehearsals, office workers popping in for a pint after a long day, and local residents who treat this as their go-to hangout.

Inside, the atmosphere feels warm and buzzy, especially in the evenings when people gather before heading upstairs to watch a performance. Accessibility is decent for a historic London pub: the main bar area is manageable, though there are a few tight corners; dogs are welcome, adding to the pub’s friendly vibe; and there’s some limited outdoor seating that’s great when the weather allows.

If I had to recommend one dish, I’d suggest you try the Sunday roast—it’s generously portioned, with succulent meat (or a veggie alternative) and all the traditional trimmings. On the drinks side, the selection of real ales is a big draw for me, and it’s clear they care about keeping their cask beer in prime condition. Prices are pretty reasonable for central London, so you won’t feel that familiar pinch you might at trendier spots nearby.

My only small gripe would be that, during peak hours, space can get quite tight in the pub’s main seating area, so finding a free table can be a bit of a scrum. A few more seats wouldn’t go amiss, though I understand the cosy layout is part of its character. With a bit of planning—perhaps arriving just before the post-work rush—you can nab a comfortable spot without trouble.

Beyond the doors of The Old Red Lion, you’ll find yourself in the heart of Angel, which is a lively spot in its own right. You’ve got the bustling market stalls at Chapel Market nearby, and Sadler’s Wells Theatre just a short walk away for more cultural immersion. There’s also a wealth of restaurants and bars in the area if you’re continuing your night out, though I often find The Old Red Lion so engaging that I’m content to linger a while longer.

This pub seamlessly combines the traditional London pub feel with a vibrant theatre scene. It’s the perfect place if you’re after a pint of well-kept real ale, a bite of classic British fare, and a dash of the performing arts. I’d recommend it to anyone searching for a genuine local experience in Angel—just be ready to immerse yourself in the lively culture and, if you’re lucky, catch an unforgettable show upstairs.